a circuit workout
An article today on Yahoo!News talks about the popularity of circuit workout gyms. These gyms specialize in providing members a quick workout that targets everything (think Curves). But nowadays, there are more choices and for both genders, inclduing boxing-style circuits.
The claim is that American will like these workouts because they can fit them in their busy schedules. Apparently, one third of health clubs in America are express workout facilities.
I remain a skeptic. I was hoping that the article would divulge information about the effectiveness of express circuit workouts, but unfortunately no such information was provided. My sister and a few aunts swear by the Curves workouts, but I'm still a fan of the good old fashion gym workout. I've read in magazines that the express circuit workout is best for people who are new to fitness and exercise and need an easy approach. I agree with this. But most go on to say that it is easy to get bored with this type of workout and eventually people will either stop working out altogether due to boredom or have to switch to another workout.
I'm skeptical about these circuits because the article said one lasted only 20 minutes. So even if you workout every weekday, you're not even getting 2 hours of exercise a week! And, let's say that these circuits make you work out at a very high intensity (which, I doubt) you would only be burning around 180 calories per workout (according to Self.com's calorie calculator based on a 145 pound woman). This does add up to 900 calories if you workout 5 times a week, but it's way below the 3,500 calories that are needed to burn to lose one pound a week.
I also think these workouts lack in cardio activity. I know that the point of circuit training is to keep you moving and keep your heart rate up, but compared to running you're not burning nearly as much calories.
One positive thing about these circuits is that strength training is added to the workout. I feel that many people, especially women, skimp on strength training due to intimidation and lack of knowledge. Although strength training may not burn as much calories as cardio, combining the two (30 min. cardio, 30 min. strength) offers a very well-rounded fitness routine. You'll be burning fat on the cardio, and building muscles that will slowly reveal themselves as the fat melts away. Much better results.
What are your thoughts on express workouts?




