I was browsing on Shape's Website a few weeks ago and saw an online poll that asked, "Would you ever take a diet pill" Interested, I submitted my answer (no!) and wondered what the results would be (I guessed 70% no, 30% yes). I got the new Shape magazine this week and sure enough, the reader poll and results were featured in the shape.com section. Surprisingly, the results were 52% yes and 48% no.
Let me be clear, I realize that this poll is in no way scientific and/or generalizable to shape readers, young women, or any group for that matter. But despite all that, I'm way alarmed by the results. More than half of the women in the poll would take a diet pill?
I realize that losing weight takes a lot of work (I've been through it) but I also am skeptical of anything that claims it's product makes losing weight easy. It's not easy. It takes willpower, it takes commitment, it takes doing things differently, changing a lifestyle, spending money and time cooking healthy meals, etc. etc. But it's so worth it.
If you (or someone you know) is a diet pill person, or someone who would consider taking these pills, maybe this will change your opinion: They aren't very effective!
Weight loss is modest for prescription diet drugs: an average of less than 5.5 Ib more than placebo at the end of one year with fenfluramine, 7 to 11 Ib for the recently approved sibutramine (Meddia, by Knoll Pharmaceutical), and 8 Ib for orlistat (Xenical, by Hoffman-La Roche). Most studies show maximum weight loss at about 20 weeks, with little or no further weight loss during long-term treatment, and weight regain when the drug is discontinued (Levitsky, 1997).
If you consume 500 calories less than what you are consuming regularly, you can lose 1-2 pounds a week. Multiply that by 52 weeks and you could lose 100 pounds in a year!
Not only do they not work well, they also are associated with major health risks (like leaky heart valves, increased blood pressure, and possible brain damage.
Americans need to learn that there isn't always an easy way out of things... especially out of obesity.